Appeals court upholds decision to block Anthem bid for Cigna

Appeals court upholds decision to block Anthem bid for Cigna
Appeals court upholds decision to block Anthem bid for Cigna
Author

30 April, 2017

After the merger was first blocked, Cigna filed a lawsuit against Anthem seeking at least $14 billion in damages, which is a lot more than the $1.85 billion contractual breakup fee.

Anthem and Cigna announced their intention to live in corporate merged bliss back in 2015.

The federal appeals court in Washington ruled by a majority of 2 to1 that the Anthem-Cigna merger would have unacceptably reduced competition in the market. Therefore, my approach to this case would require District Court resolution of one remaining question: Would Anthem-Cigna obtain lower provider rates from hospitals and doctors because of its exercise of unlawful monopsony power in the upstream market where it negotiates rates with providers? Aetna then said it was abandoning its deal.

Anthem's bid to complete the merger is likely over now.

Anthem said it was disappointed by the decision. "We are committed to completing the transaction and are now reviewing the opinion and will carefully evaluate our options", the company said in a statement.

Anthem told the DE court in a filing on Wednesday that there were "meaningful opportunities" to complete deal, saying it was seeking a settlement with the Justice Department under the new Trump administration.

Consumer groups and medical organizations also objected to the merger, which would have resulted in the country's largest health insurer.

President Donald Trump and congressional Republicans want to scrap the Affordable Care Act and replace it, but so far they have been unsuccessful. Cigna, through a company lawyer, said it has no comment at this time. The Justice Department was skeptical that any savings would be passed on to customers.

'Bachelor' star Chris Soules' 911 call made public
He tells her the tractor is not atop the man, and when she asks if Soules knows how to perform CPR, he responds he does not. Our sources say the fact Soules is famous works against him, because prosecutors don't want to appear soft on celebrities.

National Association of Conservation Districts congratulates Sonny Perdue on his new position
He also visited Cuba, China and South America as part of several trade missions aimed at growing exports for Peach State farmers. Perdue served as a state senator in Georgia before being elected governor in 2003 - the first republican governor in 130 years.

China launches first home-made aircraft carrier
By comparison, the United States has 10 carriers, four of which are deployed in the Asia-Pacific alone. Beijing in the past has told India not consider the Indian Ocean its "own backyard".

Bill Baer, the former head of the Justice Department's Antitrust Division who had made the decision to challenge both insurance mergers, said in an email that the ruling on the Anthem/Cigna deal "is a ringing endorsement of the importance of competition in health insurance markets". Indianapolis-based Anthem declined less than 1 percent to $177.89.

The decision likely puts an end to the merger, and comes on the heels of another major health insurance merger, between Aetna and Humana, also being blocked. "ORCRP000343-topic.html" class="local_link" >Aetna's planned acquisition of Humana.

The insurers have the option of appealing the case to the U.S. Supreme Court to try to save the deal.

As previously disclosed, on February 8, 2017, the U.S. District Court (the "District Court") for the District of Columbia enjoined the proposed merger between Cigna Corporation and Anthem, Inc. Of the $2.4 billion in claimed savings, Israel projected that $1.5 billion would result from Cigna customers accessing Anthem's lower rates, while $874.6 million would result from Anthem customers accessing Cigna's lower rates.

"Anthem has not explained why these projected savings would even exist", Rogers wrote.

The litigation has played out amid acrimony between Anthem and Cigna.

The American Medical Association, which represents physicians, applauded the decision. Rogers was nominated by another Democrat, President Bill Clinton, in 1993. Once it's over, it will be "harder for either Anthem or Cigna to do another deal that involves a combination of another large insurer", Mitchell Raup, an antitrust attorney from Polsinelli, told Healthcare Dive.


More news


  • 'Bachelor' star called 911 before allegedly fleeing scene

    'Bachelor' star called 911 before allegedly fleeing scene

    Cops finally arrested Chris at his home a few hours later, and he was released after posting a $10,000 bond. Wolfgram said that Soules refused to answer his door for officers, telling them to contact his attorney.

    NFL prospect denies rape report made to police; no charges

    We will have to see how much this report impacts Conley's draft status when the draft officially kicks off on Thursday night. Just a couple days prior to the 2017 NFL Draft , Conley has been accused of rape, according to a report from TMZ Sports .
    Cassini concludes final fly by of Titan

    Cassini concludes final fly by of Titan

    After buzzing Titan, Cassini coasted onward, reaching the farthest point in its orbital path around Saturn at 8:46 p.m. The earliest time Cassini is scheduled to make radio contact with Earth is 12:05am PDT (2:05am CDT) on April 27th.
  • BoJ chief warns over 'likely' delay on inflation target

    BoJ chief warns over 'likely' delay on inflation target

    While a pioneer in deploying unorthodox stimulus, the BOJ is likely to lag behind its peers in withdrawing monetary support. Japan's economy grew by 1.2% on Y-o-Y basis, in the October to December quarter, as per the data revised in last month.
    Venezuelan forces use tear gas to block latest protest march

    Venezuelan forces use tear gas to block latest protest march

    The decision was later partially reversed amid a storm of global criticism - and from Ortega Diaz herself. It excludes Canada and the U.S.
    Dutch Economic Affairs minister says still opposed to Akzo Nobel takeover

    Dutch Economic Affairs minister says still opposed to Akzo Nobel takeover

    Both previous bids were turned down on value grounds. "If they don't, PPG is very likely to take this directly to shareholders". But it has come under pressure from Elliott Management, the US hedge fund founded by billionaire Paul E.
  • Texas House OKs 'sanctuary city' ban with tough jail penalty

    Texas House OKs 'sanctuary city' ban with tough jail penalty

    Mary Gonzalez told the House that she believes the bill will expose undocumented Texas residents to more crime. Under the legislation , cities, counties and universities could no longer adopt so-called sanctuary policies.
    Prominent firm to defend 'Bachelor' star in Iowa crash case

    Prominent firm to defend 'Bachelor' star in Iowa crash case

    According to his obituary in the Waterloo-Cedar Falls Courier Mosher was the father of two children and had three grandchildren. Since the accident, Soules has deleted his social media accounts. "Yes, yes", a winded and upset but lucid Soules replies.
    Call of Duty: WWII fully revealed with first trailer, screens, game details

    Call of Duty: WWII fully revealed with first trailer, screens, game details

    We have plenty of information on Call of Duty: WW2, which was revealed earlier today via a livestream. Call of Duty: WWII will be released for PC, Xbox One and PlayStation 4 on November 3, 2017 .
  • Australian Olympic Committee Launches Investigation After Bullying Scandal

    Australian Olympic Committee Launches Investigation After Bullying Scandal

    Moreover, Coates' ally, the media director Mike Tancred, has been stood down from all AOC duties until bullying allegations against him were resolved.
    Quarterly EPS Forecast Review: PayPal Holdings, Inc. (PYPL)

    Quarterly EPS Forecast Review: PayPal Holdings, Inc. (PYPL)

    A month ago, they told us to expect earnings of US$0.42 per share while three months ago their EPS consensus estimate was US$0.42. The current share price indicates that stock is -1.33% away from its one year high and is moving 30.62% ahead of its 52-week low.
    Death toll in Venezuela's political unrest rises to at least 24

    Death toll in Venezuela's political unrest rises to at least 24

    No country has ever withdrawn from the OAS since it was created in 1948 and it's not clear how complicated the process would be. Be proactive - Use the "Flag as Inappropriate" link at the upper right corner of each comment to let us know of abusive posts.