SCOTUS Hears MO Religious Discrimination Case

President Donald Trump watches as Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy administers the judicial oath to Judge Neil Gorsuch during a re-enactment in the Rose Garden of the White House
How a Supreme Court Ruling on a Missouri Playground's Funding Could Alter California's School Voucher Ban
Author

20 April, 2017

A challenge to a 2015 court decision invalidating a Colorado voucher programme is pending before the justices, awaiting the Trinity Lutheran case's outcome. - The Supreme Court on Wednesday heard arguments about whether a state benefit program could exclude churches due to their religious status.

The court must decide whether Missouri is entitled to reject a church grant to use recycled tires to resurface a playground.

Citing discrimination, the church sued the state, and although it lost in the lower courts, it is now looking for a SCOTUS ruling that would ensure that schools run by churches can not be excluded from government programs providing assistance to non-profit organizations. The church sued and lost in the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals, and then appealed to the nation's highest court. The state argued in its brief to the court that Trinity Lutheran congregants are still free to practice their religion; they just won't be able to do it with state funding.

It's no wonder-the justices had a lot of time to think about this case, since they granted review in January 2016 and appeared to hold off in hearing the case until a ninth justice was confirmed.

Newly elected Missouri Gov. Eric Greitens, a Republican, recently announced that his administration would reverse course and allow religious organizations to apply for and be eligible for such state grants.

Trinity Lutheran sued, noting its grant request was for a non-religious objective. Gorsuch asked. "And second, how do we tell the difference between the two, if that's the line we're going to draw?"

The state didn't get many converts.

What does this have to do with Colorado?

The Trinity Lutheran case is one of the most anticipated of the current court term.

Former Missouri Supreme Court Justice Mike Wolff believes it does. While a judge for a USA appeals court in Colorado, Gorsuch argued that religious freedom protected the store chain Hobby Lobby from the Affordable Care Act's requirement that it would have to offer its employees free birth control coverage.

Facebook has 60 engineers working on controlling computers from your brain
So far , this ability to "hear" with patterns of stimulation on the skin also seems much closer to a real consumer technology. While neither of these projects will yield a gadget that you can buy, Dugan said she can imagine it happening eventually.

Alex Jones' Court Defense: I'm Just a 'Performance Artist'
Read the full American-Statesman story here. "You get in my face with that, I'll beat your g****n ass, you son of a b***h". Judging Jones based on his broadcasts, Wilhite said, would be like judging Jack Nicholson from his portrayal of the Joker.

Major League Baseball celebrates Jackie Robinson's breaking of color barrier
Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier in 1947 by becoming the first African-American to play baseball in the major leagues. Many historians believe Robinson's breakthrough was an early step that eventually led to other civil rights breakthroughs.

Aside from the religious liberty element, the case is being watched for the implications of how the Supreme Court will rule with Gorsuch on the bench. But this argument is incomplete: religious organizations benefit from all sorts of tax breaks, and the programs they run directly - even ones which don't seem obviously "religious" - are often categorized as part of their "ministry" in order to take advantage of those.

If the high court rules in favor of the church, Michael Bindas of the Institute for Justice, which supports the church, says it could result in a major shift in the law on churches and public funding. As the founders recognized, separation of church and state is an indispensable requirement of individual liberty, protecting religious institutions from potential interference from the government, and vice-versa.

The state ranked Trinity fifth on the list of 44 applicants, but refused it permission to participate.

Liberal Justice Sonia Sotomayor was the most outspoken in backing Missouri's ban, noting the difficulty states could face determining whether funds going to a religious entity are being used for a secular purposes.

James R. Layton, a lawyer for the state, said on the other hand that the clause in Missouri's constitution that prohibits the granting of taxpayer monies to any church, sect, or religion, simply means the state should not be "forced" to release money for Trinity Lutheran Church. The court Friday asked the church and the state to tell it whether the governor's announcement affects the case.

"The church now has the ability to receive taxpayer dollars", Jeffrey Mittman, executive director of the ACLU of Missouri, said. Three-quarters of the USA states have provisions similar to Missouri's barring funding for religious entities.

The justices wondered whether church schools could seek public money for computers and textbooks. These "no-aid" clauses safeguard religious freedom by ensuring that citizens have freedom of conscience to choose which religions (if any) they will voluntarily support.

Chief Justice John Roberts, meanwhile, wanted to know if a state program that gives school groups tours of the state capitol could discriminate against religious schools.

ADF said it is defending the long-held First Amendment principle that the government can not exclude religious organizations from government programs that provide purely nonreligious benefits.


More news


  • Charlotte to host ACC Football Championship Game through 2020

    Charlotte to host ACC Football Championship Game through 2020

    The NCAA announced tournament sites for the next five years Tuesday which includes North Carolina locations. Roy Cooper signed a compromise bill March 30 after it was approved by the Republican-controlled legislature.
    Could Romelu Lukaku return to Chelsea?

    Could Romelu Lukaku return to Chelsea?

    Plus Mills takes us through all the contenders for the PFA Player of the Year and the Young Player of the Year awards. Phoenix Rising FC was one of 12 groups to officially submit an MLS expansion application to the league in January.
    Palestinian Intifada Leader Announces Hunger Strike Via the New York Times

    Palestinian Intifada Leader Announces Hunger Strike Via the New York Times

    Opinion polls indicate that Barghouti enjoys widespread support in his quest to replace Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas. Israeli authorities argue administrative detention protects at-risk informants and is needed for the country's security.
  • Trump admin. declines to brand China a currency manipulator

    Japan and South Korea are concerned Trump will overlook China's aggression toward its neighbors. Trump said. "So, I'm dealing with China with great respect".

    'Star Wars: The Last Jedi' teaser trailer lands in our galaxy

    Fisher's brother Todd had previously said his sister would feature in the movie posthumously, after her death in December 2017. We now have our first peek at the next chapter in the Star Wars saga, " Star Wars: Episode VIII - The Last Jedi".

    Brief marriage precedes fatal San Bernardino school shooting

    Anderson had a criminal history that included weapons charges, drug charges and accusations of domestic violence, Burguan said. Burguan said it appeared Anderson was trying to contact his wife to convince her to return home, but she resisted.
  • Pence says America's 'sword stands ready' if North Korea attacks

    Pence says America's 'sword stands ready' if North Korea attacks

    Asked what North Korea must do, he repeated that " all options are on the table, and there they will remain". Vice President Mike Pence said it is in U.S. interest to negotiate trade deals on a bilateral basis.

    Trump Signs Anti-Planned Parenthood Bill As Anti-Choice Activists Look On

    Federal law already prohibits government money for abortion, except in cases of rape or incest or to save a woman's life. Trump even invited top right-wing activists to the Oval Office to watch him sign the legislation.

    Car bomb kills at least 39 Syria evacuees

    According to a Sputnik source in Aleppo, the blast supposedly was caused by a suicide attacker who detonated an explosive device. At least 80 buses left Fuaa and Kafraya in Idlib province in the northwest, an AFP correspondent in rebel-held territory said.
  • UC Berkeley Cancels Ann Coulter Speech Over Protest Concerns

    UC Berkeley Cancels Ann Coulter Speech Over Protest Concerns

    Coulter had been invited to campus by two student groups, and was scheduled to appear at UC Berkeley on April 27. We are going to need help with big guys at the doors checking student IDs.
    Bulls Take on Celtics in Playoffs

    Bulls Take on Celtics in Playoffs

    It's key when you have a point guard like him that controls the whole game- you just have to play. "Tonight, our job was easy". Their star, Isaiah Thomas , lost his 22-year-old sister, Chyna, in a vehicle accident the day before the playoffs started.

    WWE Smackdown Live Results 4/18/17

    Charlotte said it has been seven days since she moved from Monday Night Raw to SmackDown Live in the "superstar shakeup". NXT tag team The Bollywood Boyz debuted on the show, helping Mahal win the match by holding Sami Zayn's legs.